Don't see what Vista offers over XP except a new GUI?

Island Dog

Join Date 06/2003

+1048

Very interesting article. Thanks for posting.

Successfully updated karma reason!

yes, very informative. I really think Vista is going to be a success. It seems Microsoft is on the money here. Thanks for posting!

Successfully updated karma reason!

Thanks for the link. I hadn't seen a thorough preview of Vista's features until now-- definitely worth reading...

Successfully updated karma reason!

And they still credit Konfabulator with the concept of widgets...

Successfully updated karma reason!

thomassen

Join Date 01/2003

+10

Funny how people will say product X stole a feature from product Y. If product X didn't implement the new hot feature from product Y they'd be going; "But they should have added feature [whatever] from product Y."
Imagine how horrible software would be if noone would implement features allready used in other software. People should just be happy they got more choices instead of bitching about who was first. I know Stardock was out first with widgets/gadget, all though they wheren't called that at that time, but that's just semantics. But in the end I really don't care who made it first. It's a really cool feature and I'm glad there are competitors.

Successfully updated karma reason!

Well, it certainly looks good. But I'm not convinced I should upgrade right away, if at all. Since so much was changed, I bet there will be major compatability problems. And there wasn't much discussion in that article about the DRM and media restrictions. But I admit, from that article, it looks a lot better than what I thought it was.

Successfully updated karma reason!

I'll be upgrading to Windows for Workgroups later this year

Successfully updated karma reason!

Re: #5

If that happened, only Apple would be using a GUI. Then Apple would probably have a monopoly, and Microsoft would be the "holy savior" with Bill Gates as god.

Successfully updated karma reason!

Interesting article though. Sounds intriguing.

Successfully updated karma reason!

starkers

Join Date 05/2004

+1153

I've always appreciated a good 'view', so Vista has to be on my agenda with its more than attractive under the hood features/additions. The GUI is fairly irrelevant to me at the end of the day...the novelty will wear off quickly and I'll be installing my Stardock proggies, post haste. Doubt very much Vista's new look will last a week before I'm plastering my screen with skins from WC....such is my need for variety

Successfully updated karma reason!

I'll be upgrading to Windows for Workgroups later this year

Wow, I am still using "Buttons for DOS 6.2", but I promise I'll upgrade next year

Posted via WinCustomize Browser/Stardock Central

Successfully updated karma reason!

Another article to check out........

"Why Windows Vista will suck" at downloadsquad
http://www.downloadsquad.com/2006/03/02/why-windows-vista-will-suck/

Successfully updated karma reason!

thomassen

Join Date 01/2003

+10

It seemed to me that the guy in that article was moaning over the fact that features existing in OSX and Linux finally got implemented in Windows.
As for the steep hardware: why not utilize the power that exist? Where's the point of having it idle? And isn't Windows mostly distrubited through new PC's anyways?

And while me might sit with his Linux box and have every software he needs, there are people, like me who cant have every software I need on a Linux box. People have different needs. No OS fits everyone.

I just checked the comments for that article and it's being slaughtered: http://www.desktoplinux.com/cgi-bin/board/UltraBoard.pl?Action=ShowPost&Board=talkbacks&Post=289

Successfully updated karma reason!

He never really disagreed with the ExtremeTech article. He just said Microsoft 'stole' the ideas from other software, or that Linux or OSX is better. Look to me like someone is trying to find any reason for Vista to not be too good. In fact, because an anti-Vista person couldn't come up with any actual criticism, I more impressed by it.

I think software should always use the most up to date hardware. Seems kind of silly for software to lag 6 or 9 months behind.

I agree with Starkers. The look of the Vista GUI is probably the least important thing to me. Once WB and the other OD programs are available for Vista, I'm sure most of us will drop the Aero default, and get into skins, which I'm sure will be kickass.

There aren't many programs I use that would work on Linux, so I have no use for it. And I simply don't like using Macs. I wish my school would put at least a couple PCs in the labs. Oh well.

Successfully updated karma reason!

Well I am impressed. It seems that they are doing an almost complete overhaul on it and those ideas sound good to me. I am not too concerned about the idea of needing better hardware to use it, after all, the point of upgrading to a new OS would be to have better performance. You can't expect a VW to perform better simply because you put a corvette engine in it.

I plan on building a computer using some of the latest and best hardware out now or by the time Vista is out. I guess a new OS would be a good idea as well.

Successfully updated karma reason!

thomassen

Join Date 01/2003

+10

agree with Starkers. The look of the Vista GUI is probably the least important thing to me. Once WB and the other OD programs are available for Vista, I'm sure most of us will drop the Aero default, and get into skins, which I'm sure will be kickass.

Yea, same here. Only thing. We haven't really heard anything about being able to skin the Aero mode. I know you can change colour tint and opacity. But nothing about changing the look of the UI it self like we do with Visual Styles (what will be Vista Express).

Successfully updated karma reason!

I think Windowblinds is being redone to work and take advantage of what Vista offers, rather than just emulate it. At least I hope so.

Successfully updated karma reason!

very interesting indeed, thanks for sharing...

Successfully updated karma reason!

Nope still not interested, XP does a good enough job. For those who think Vista will be security paradise think again, while what has been done will/may close a lot of current holes do you really think people won't find new ones? Their are nerds out their who enjoy dong that kind of cr@p!

Microsoft said their would be a minor release between Whistler (XP) and Blackcomb which was codenamed Longhorn, it still seems like they are playing that business model.

If you work in an IT support role that interface is going to be a nightmare if you have customers who are not very computer literate (and don't put much effort in)

Successfully updated karma reason!

thomassen

Join Date 01/2003

+10

For those who think Vista will be security paradise think again, while what has been done will/may close a lot of current holes do you really think people won't find new ones?

And there is an OS out there that hasn't got secotury holes?

Microsoft said their would be a minor release between Whistler (XP) and Blackcomb which was codenamed Longhorn, it still seems like they are playing that business model.

Windows Vista isn't going to be as big an update as Microsoft originally said. I was really disappointed to see WinFS go. But I do belive that the amount of features in Vista is enough to consider it. It is after all five years since XP and they have made a progress.
Mind you, I will probably only upgrade my main computer to Vista. There is a certain point to where it's feasible to upgrade.

f you work in an IT support role that interface is going to be a nightmare if you have customers who are not very computer literate (and don't put much effort in)

I'd say that the only OS's that has interfaces good enough for the major crowd is Windows and OSX.

Successfully updated karma reason!

Why do people keep complaining about the IT support problems? It seems like such a minor problem. If people aren't computer literate in XP, they won't be in Vista. Vista won't make things better or worse for people who don't know what they're doing anyway.

Yeah, every OS has holes. But at least according to the article, Microsoft isolated parts of Vista so a virus or worm can't do as much damage. Yet.

Successfully updated karma reason!

wtf....you cant SEE what it offers apart from the graphical side...THE GRAPHICAL SIDE IS ALL YOU PHYSICALLY CAN SEE, what a silly post...google it, read about the features instead of whinging (I didnt read the link I'm too lazy)

Successfully updated karma reason!

thomassen

Join Date 01/2003

+10

wtf....you cant SEE what it offers apart from the graphical side...THE GRAPHICAL SIDE IS ALL YOU PHYSICALLY CAN SEE, what a silly post...google it, read about the features instead of whinging (I didnt read the link I'm too lazy)

If you had read the article or this post, you would have noticed it was about what Vista offers except it's graphical side.

If people aren't computer literate in XP, they won't be in Vista.

Not in any OS really. But best choice would be Windows or OSX.

Successfully updated karma reason!

starkers

Join Date 05/2004

+1153

I think Windowblinds is being redone to work and take advantage of what Vista offers,

Brad has already stated that Stardock is working on the Vista/WB situation and there will be a compatible WB that ulilises the Vista features.
Being a MS partner, Stardock can access the Vista beta's and tech information and may already have some development under way.....but it's a fairly safe bet that Stardock will have a number of Vista ready programs for the release of Vista, if not shortly afterwards.

What beats me, though, is all the flaming and carboshing of Vista when it hasn't even been released....particularly when alot of it comes from some who haven't even tried out the beta releases.....and even then, the beta releases are no true indication of the final product.

No OS is ever going to be perfect, and there'll always be some dropkick trying to exploit vunerabilities, if and when they find them, but it would seem that MS has put a great deal more effort into securing Vista than any other OS it has released.

Quite frankly, I don't give a rat's who thought of this and that first, I'm impressed with what I've read and managed to learn about Vista so far, and I fully intend to try it out, regardless of half-assed 'opinions' emanating from those who flame for flaming sake. With the amount of time, money and effort that's gone into Vista, I can't see MS just putting it out there and not providing ongoing support for whatever vunerabilities are found, so yeah, I have confidence in it rather than doubts.

Successfully updated karma reason!

Thanks Thomas. I never personally really thought Vista was just a new GUI. I knew of these features under the hood.

However, I am scared to see the price tag. I personally believe to get the best use out of Vista and my mobile devices I'd need the Ultimate Edition. I'd expect to see that (personally) to hit around the $500+ USD price range. Microsoft tends to shoot for an "All or nothing" concept. That has never went very well with me, that's the only reason I may not upgrade.

But, I did learn a lot more about Vista thanks to the link you posted and I appreciate you sharing it with us Thomas. If it's under $350 USD for the Ultimate, then I'll upgrade.

Successfully updated karma reason!