CATMANDU21 CATMANDU21

My two cents on Stardock.............

My two cents on Stardock.............

In my opinion, Stardock's out of control on the Premium Dream pricing scheme. The real reason this site is hot is because of the free submissions made by aspiring artists who frequent this site like TheMasterBaron, AzDude and others who have really brought Stardock's Dream Site area all of the hype it has and have also saved Microsoft's butts. Stardock's Premium Dreams have had little impact on the overall success of Dreamscene's, if anything Stardock and Microsoft are riding the coattails of all of Stardock's free submitters. Also realize that if the free users stopped submitting, Stardock would be dead in the water on Dreamscenes. Stardock shouldn't have any premium Dreamscenes, they should be free contributions for all the hits and revenue their users produce. They can charge for Object Desktop, Windowsblinds and the rest of their 100+ other products they have for sale on their site. Just to add, my opinion on why Stardock is charging is because Microsoft made things much harder for Stardock with Vista. In the XP days, Stardock brought Vista-like interface changes to the table. In that era, Stardock cornered the market on GUI customization. Today, things aren't so rosy. Vista performs many of Stardock's Object Desktop features natively, leaving Stardock to find new ways to make money. Understand Stardock's days are numbered in the GUI customiztion business. As OS's get prettier with age like Vista and MacOS, Stardock's software can now be considered "bloatware" and a waste of precious RAM and processor time.

Also, isn't Stardock getting any Microsoft kickbacks being that Dreamscenes and Deskscapes/Dreammaker are collaborative efforts as they work into one another, I mean Stardock has bailed Microsoft out on what would have been a pathetic release with only 10+ dreams available from Microsoft when Stardock currently brought over 200 more Dreams to the table? Finally, if you purchase any of these Premium Dreams, you'll have to activate this product, a little overboard for a $10 wallpaper. Even better, if your system should fail and you are reinstalling Windows and you don't take backup images like a friend of mine who purchased one, then chances are your going to have to call/e-mail Stardock to reactivate your Premium Dream as this activation is paying attention to your SID's when activated to prevent piracy so a reinstall or sysprep would force reactivation, yuck! Saddest part, after the paying customer has all these hoops to jump through, I can guarantee crackers have already infiltrated the activation so in the end the guy paying the $10 feels like, um..........

Hopefully, Stardock's work in the GUI business will not be in vain, leading to a buyout or takeover by Microsoft being that your GUI enhancement's have influenced Vista greatly. In the end Stardock could take over the GUI development portion of the next Windows OS after Vista, which would buy Stardock more time in the game. Some may say it's crazy, but look at the Winternals acquisition. Winternals showed Microsoft how to use System Restore and make it work. They also introduced Microsoft as well as BartPE, UBCD and Reatogo to the bootable Windows environment, which changed the face of Vista as alot of Winternals ERCD's features are integrated into Vista's install DVD. Business constantly changes and evolves, eventually Stardock's position in the market will change drastically, hopefully for the better!!
24,601 views 112 replies
Reply #76 Top

Well to be honest, I care more about a $10 wallpaper than most politicians

A $10 wallpaper is more intelligent.....

......should run for election....

Reply #77 Top
Well to be honest, I care more about a $10 wallpaper than most politicians..


Yeah, me too....in fact, I care more about a .00002 cent piece of toilet paper than I do about any politician. (don't blame me....you're the one who started the "I don't respect" politicians stuff )

A $10 wallpaper is more intelligent.....

......should run for election....


Now that, I think, is taking it a bit too far....why bother with the election bit - let's just install them.
Reply #78 Top
Lightbulb!

Take all the premium dreams.

Sell ad space in them, or pop up ads that the user can't cancel, etc.

Release them for free, and make a ton of money on ad revenue.

Do you want that to happen, or do you want to pay $10?

What's a dream again?
Reply #79 Top
Didn't sleep a wink last night...in fact, I've slept very little since this thread went up. Why? I'll tell you why, it's a conspiracy I tell ya, a conspiracy.....

Picture this...a young Frogboy, messing around with his boring old Windows 3.1, comes up with a snazzy way to make it look so much prettier....with coloured taskbars, pretty icons and a sweet looking cursor. Frogboy then sat back and cast his eyes upon what he had made....and he saw it was good.

On the second day, Frogboy showed his snazzy new desktop to his friends and colleagues at work, and they too saw it was good. Seeing that his friends were impressed, Frogboy let them have it on their PC's.....and he sat back and saw it was good

On the third day, Frogboy decided he was sick of working for a boss and opened his own company to make customisation software....knowing in his heart that desktop themes would flourish around the world and over the internet. How did Frogboy know he would succeed? Well, because he saw that his friends had become addicted to their newly skinned desktops and saw that they wanted more, more, more.....

On the fourth day, Frogboy gathered together some of his colleagues and closest friends to inform them of his decision and invite them on board, and they too knew it was good.
At their first board meeting, they developed a business plan and a strategy to market this new fangled software....something to ensure they would never ever fail.

This, folks, is where you come in! Ever wonder why you're so addicted to skinning and customising your desktop? Well I'll tell ya....subliminal messages....little cues and prompts to keep you subscribing to Stardock software. Yes folks, that's what keeps you coming back over and over again....subliminal messages. They're on your monitor screen and in your PC speakers...but don't bother looking for them because they're inaudible and invisible ordinarily to the naked eye. You don't think Frogboy was going to use technology that's easily detectable, do you? To see the subliminal messages on your screen, you must be able to sit in an air tight room for 15 minutes under ultra violet lighting....and that is not recommended. And there's no point in turning off your speakers, either....the subliminal sounds also permeate through the screen. You may not be able to see or hear these subliminal messages, your not supposed to, but believe me, they're there.

So there you have it, folks, it was more by design than accident that you've become hooked on skinning and customisation....it's sort of like a mass hypnosis and totally unavoidable. Mind you, it's not such a bad thing, so let's have three cheers for Frogboy and Stardock for this wonderful technology which delivers countless hours of PC pleasure to countless people all around the world. Hip hip.......
Reply #80 Top
Hold the phone! The end is near?! I haven't been on this site since early spring because they were saying the same thing, and I thought it was all over... Now I find out the end didn't even come, but it IS near...AGAIN! OMG!

Wait before I run for cover. I know prophecy isn't an exact science but could you be a little more specific? Do you mean like "near" the end of the week, or did you mean month? Year? Decade?
No not really   I just got into modding my motorcycle more than windows. It's good to see you guys are still going great I just saw the announcement for the new skinstudio beta release. Just the thing to get me screwing up, I mean skinning windows again
Reply #81 Top
Hold the phone! The end is near?!


Oh dear, another soothsayer...prophet of doom...the end is nigh type....God shalt smite thee down if thouest doth not repent.

I remember one of those sandwich board types when I was a kid, pounding the pavement with his imminent doom message to all us sinners....yep, the world was going to end in 1968 and we were all going to perish in a modern day Sodom and Gomorrah.

Well, it obviously didn't happen then, nor did it on numerous other dates they proclaimed to be the end of the world, so why should we believe it now....but just in case, I've stocked up on extra food and dozens of candles....you know, to try riding it out in the basement.
Reply #82 Top


I have always said that these "premium" dreams should be free for Object Desktop subscribers.


Desktop Earth, the most popular premium dream of all time, is already available for free for Object Desktop users. Two additional free premium dreams are about to be released for it.


But that doesn't mean all premium dreams will be made available for Object Desktop users.


 



Well they should be. Again I need some reason to renew my OD account which is about to expire and the existing updates may not be quite enough. It's just my feedback. Take it however you see fit. I still think you guys are missing a grteat marketing opportunity here.
Reply #83 Top
This post was moved from another forum. Here are some of my responses. As I can see I have upset many Stardock users and actually I am on your side. I understand you all enjoy Stardock products, but to blindly defend a corporation you don't work for, own, or have any deep knowledge about would seem less wise then my unpopular opinion. Here's the rest of my rant, flame me if you like, but it's the fans that make this site, not Stardock.

Some Responses.......

"I can't really say whether the free submissions are the "real reason" people come here." - That I find the biggest insult, not only Dreams, but Wallpapers and the other user contributed creations. Stardock's users are the real reason the hit count is good around here. Customers usually don't hang around a vendor's site just because they like their product and want to hang around and watch the home page. Stardock's users, from wallpaper creators to full fledged artists, make 95% of the total contribultions for content on this site. Using Deskscapes for example, Stardock provided the software and about 10-15 dreams to wet the appetite. The users in return came up with the other 200+ dreams helping Stardock to "have" a product. Had the artists not made those 200+ dream contributions, users would have been gone a long time ago because nobody hangs around a forum talking about the same old 10 dreams forever, do they?

"There's a lot of erroneous statements in what you say above. First off, I am not aware of a single feature of Object Desktop that is in Windows Vista." - exactly my point; Microsoft's improvements in Vista's GUI have put Stardock in an uncomfortable position. Microsoft threw Stardock a bone with Dreamscene's since Microsoft totally screwed Stardock's niche market all up on Vista. Like I said, Object Desktop on Vista IS BLOATWARE!!! In Stardock's heyday in the XP-era, Stardock had something unique to bring, today OS's bring it natively withhout 3rd Party intervention.

The other primary mistake you make has to do with what you consider "bloatware". - again, you stated that Vista and Object Desktop are kind of useless together so you've answered your own question.

"WindowBlinds, for instance, not only is faster than Aero, but it vastly reduces the power consumption." - So your saying that Vista Ultimate users are going to actually disable Aero in favor of WindowBlinds? You've definitely lost it now!! The dream customer is an Ultimate customer, the user who want's all of Microsoft's features and is willing to pay a premium for it. For that same user to disable Aero in favor of Windowblinds, why buy Ultimate then? Why not buy Vista Basic and save yourself the $200 or even stick with XP! So the Ultimate user is in essence paying $200 more for Dreamscenes, and Hold em' Poker. Again, most customers I know don't like throwing money away, your plan is insane!

"Why should you care if you activate a $10 wallpaper? The benefit is that activation makes it much easier for users to re-download in the future." - I don't care personally, however I was speaking for the customer who does care. Microsoft always talks about the "benefits" of activation and I haven't seen it yet. At least Microsoft is protecting a $400 product with activation like Windows Vista for an example, Stardock is making the customer inconvenienced by protecting their $10 wallpaper. Greater software has been offered with less headaches.

Even better, if your system should fail and you are reinstalling Windows and you don't take backup images like a friend of mine who purchased one, then chances are your going to have to call/e-mail Stardock to reactivate your Premium Dream; This is completely untrue. - untrue? So your saying if I reinstall Windows and attempt to reinstall my Premium Dream, no re-activation will be required as my Premium Dream will recognize that I have already registered and that even though my computer's Windows installation is now entirely different, highly unlikely. If this is true, try to pass on one of your premium dreams to a friend as a test and give your friend your registration info and see if he can install the Dream, how's it going?

Stardock has no intention of being bought out by Microsoft or anyone else. - Neither did PeopleSoft, Enron, Worldcomm or anyone else out there but guess what! Whether Stardock will be acquired by another company hinges solely on Stardocks' financials and their future viability. Stardock only has as much control as their business practices dictate. Bigger companies have talked your talk and 10 years later, found themselves eating those words. When people get bought out, it's usually not by choice, remember that!!

I understand that you have to show your vendor loyalty being that your working for Stardock, however your points were weak at best. As I said, I'm not anti-Stardock! I just don't like the direction on the Deskscapes\Dreamscenes pricing scheme simply put. Like I also said, I credit Stardock with many of Vista's native GUI featureset so actually I have given Stardock a compliment. All businesses aren't perfect, I'm simply pointing to an area that Stardock needs to work on. Thanks again for your time.

LINK TO ENTIRE POST
WWW Link
Reply #84 Top
"There's a lot of erroneous statements in what you say above. First off, I am not aware of a single feature of Object Desktop that is in Windows Vista." - exactly my point; Microsoft's improvements in Vista's GUI have put Stardock in an uncomfortable position. Microsoft threw Stardock a bone with Dreamscene's since Microsoft totally screwed Stardock's niche market all up on Vista. Like I said, Object Desktop on Vista IS BLOATWARE!!! In Stardock's heyday in the XP-era, Stardock had something unique to bring, today OS's bring it natively withhout 3rd Party intervention.


Maybe it's just me...but I think you're getting that backwards. Vista doesn't have a dock, Vista doesn't offer easy icon changing on the fly (in fact, I thought it doesn't offer any icon changing at all?), Vista doesn't have triggered dreams, Vista doesn't have a full-fledged gadget system, etc. So how is it bloatware if Vista *doesn't* have any of that stuff? How does Vista do any of that natively that ODNT currently offers?
Reply #85 Top

CATMANDU21 ...your last comment [#83] is merely an opinion, none of which is based in any semblance of reality.  At best it simply does not apply [bears no relevance].

It's all based on a claim that commenters here have no 'deep knowledge about [Stardock]' which would presuppose you do and thus your comments bear more weight?

Let's just suppose no-one here has a 'deep knowledge', ergo any and all opinions are equally invalid, being based on speculation.

Some here have an extensive history/association with Stardock and its products, not merely in the current Vista age...or prior...XP, but perhaps all the way back before the Windows OS itself.

Hypotheticals are good....we all enjoy Fantasy/S-F, too, but in any situation such as relative knowledge and historical understanding, some of the opinions expressed here will have more pith/substance, being based in fact...

Reply #86 Top
I understand that you have to show your vendor loyalty being that your working for Stardock, however your points were weak at best.


Personally, I dont work for them.

For a $10 wallpaper, a Senate investigation would not be appropriate, they have more important things to do.

Dont do a King Canute, you are not going to pursuade the world to get excited over the validity or otherwise of Stardock's intentions connected with a $10 wallpaper, and then go on a meaningful crusade for the Holy Grail of wallpapers

There is a famous saying:

"When you are in a hole, stop digging"

Regards
Zy
Reply #87 Top
As I can see I have upset many Stardock users


Nope...to upset a Stardock user you'd actually have to say something (sensible) regarding its imminent closure....then back it up with fact. Other than that, we're pretty much unflappable and implicitly trusting of Stardock.

So, as another wise Stardock customer/WC member said......

"When you are in a hole, stop digging"


Reply #88 Top
[size="1"]

Holy Crap! I been using Stardock products for about 15 years give or take a couple. Its been so long ago that I can't remember, lol, guess my age is showing. I was addicted with my first Windowblind, can't remember which one it was, age showing again. I just remember it had something pretty in it, that was unique, and I liked it a lot. (Thanks Frogboy, and all of you who have made me happy all these years.)

I don't think that it's fair to slam a group of people who have worked so hard to make a lot of people's lives a little more pleasant each day, by making their their computer screens a little more colorful, and enjoyable over all these years. All over $10.00, no less.

I know it been a while since the original post was made, and his reply too, but hopefully he has his meds straighten out now.

Reply #89 Top
I know it been a while since the original post was made, and his reply too, but hopefully he has his meds straighten out now.


I think he's gone,I heard a faint 'pop' as he disappeared up his own backside.    
Reply #90 Top
Im guessing in his Almost 2 months of being a member hes gotten a much better working knowledge of Stardock, WC and its Members than those of us who have been here for years and years and years.....Funny i don't remember seeing him in the Stardock chat room gathering intel.......

Ironic isnt it?

the new born telling us WE have Little working knowledge of Stardock/WC so our opinions arent valid.....LOL what a laugh....


think before speaking..thx


Reply #91 Top
Holy Crap!


Oh I'm so glad you found a priest who'd come n' give his blessing. Was worried after all that blasphemy agin Stardock n' its customers that we'd all end up going to HELL.

I haven't been around Srardock/WC as long as you, only around 4 years, but I feel pretty much the same way....and certainly there is nothing here over-priced, it's all good value for money/worth every penny.

I think he's gone,I heard a faint 'pop' as he disappeared up his own backside


I wondered what that noise was....followed by that rather pungent smell. Thanks for solving the mystery....now I'll be able to apologise to the person who was standing next to me at the time....vehement protests of innocence did not deter my finger pointing that they'd let rip a colon cough.

Funny i don't remember seeing him in the Stardock chat room gathering intel.....


Think Bobby answered that one....as to why not. If somehow he manages to extricate himself from that dark orifice (and thoroughy showers first) its probable he'll turn up over a TGT Soft after the reception he got here.
Reply #92 Top
I can't believe you guys are still up in arms about my comments. Stardock is a product, not a buddy who hangs out at your house or your family! I simply believed and still believe there is no need to charge for premium dreams, while still making a profit, end of story. I wasn't bashing any of the readers in the forum or using foul language to express myself. If a person can't make anything other than a pro-Stardock comment, then this forum is truly in trouble. I would hope you all would look at my comments with an open mind and understand my stance would benefit you, the consumer, user and forum member.

I've looked around and I'm not the only one complaining about the dream prices or the product itself. Even Stardock employees aren't in the forum pushing Stardock like you guys, it truly shows how blind the common Stardock user is. It's funny, the users who bash me above respond with no conviction. Is it the "cool" thing to do to bash a guy who's not a blind follower? All of you need to grow up and utilize a more mature method of responding to a forum poster so we instead could have an educated, fact finding debate, rather than a "who can bash the new forum member who doesn't like Stardock" contest. This gives other reading forum members no reason to voice their views here with such an unfriendly group. Use you head, you want people to post here, right?
Reply #93 Top
Its very simple, no one is going to get excited over a $10 wallpaper, $50 maybe, but not the former. Dont like it? Live with it.

In a way you do deserve some thanks - I wasnt a full blown Blinds yaddie yadda user, but having had the mind focused on it by this thread, its likely I'll go for it at those low prices.

They say all publicity is good publicity - do you work for Stardock by any chance ?   
Reply #94 Top
Don't work for Stardock, but well said Zydor; their are more important things around here then this comment, unfortunately mindless users like Starkers with their comments like "Yeah, 'tis sad, isn't it! Personally, I think Stardock should start using its 'press any key' tazer technology on anyone who complains/questions its pricing policy." How about you go back to school and read about freedom of speech because where you come from, there obviously is none.

Remember that thought when your Mommy is at the voting booth next time, Fidel Castro's unfortunately not on the ballet, sorry..............
Reply #95 Top
Don't work for Stardock, but well said Zydor; their are more important things around here then this comment, unfortunately mindless users like Starkers with their comments like "Yeah, 'tis sad, isn't it! Personally, I think Stardock should start using its 'press any key' tazer technology on anyone who complains/questions its pricing policy." How about you go back to school and read about freedom of speech because where you come from, there obviously is none.

Remember that thought when your Mommy is at the voting booth next time, Fidel Castro's unfortunately not on the ballet, sorry..............


You are not only wrong but you insult people without know them
Not cause you talk about something that unfortunately you seem don't know at all but cause you Attack others users, and that it's forbidden
Now for information this is a forum where people can dialog together not a Bash area.
Arguments yes insults not.
Again own opinion
Reply #96 Top
unfortunately mindless users like Starkers with their comments like "Yeah, 'tis sad, isn't it! Personally, I think Stardock should start using its 'press any key' tazer technology on anyone who complains/questions its pricing policy." How about you go back to school and read about freedom of speech because where you come from, there obviously is none.


You've obviously missed the tongue firmly pressed into my cheek...if you take a look at the 'Joe user is Joke User' thread, you will see that I jest and refer to non-existent Stardock technology....like Stardock could zap people should they complain and press any key on their keyboard.

Also, refer back to posts 79 & 81....again, more tongue in cheek stuff to lighten things up.

You are entitled to your opinion, as is anyone else here, but being that the majority is satisfied with Stardock's products and services, be prepared that few will support complaints or arguments against Stardock, particularly on a forum that Stardock provides to its customers.

Oh, and we do have freedom of speech here in Oz....for example, I could publicly say that lil Johnny (our Prime Minister) "is a low-life lying piece of pond scum who could lie under 40 foot of sewage with a mouth chocked full of parliamentary privileges, and wouldn't tell the truth if it were indelibly stamped to his tongue" and nobody would bat an eyelid.
Reply #97 Top

I can't believe you guys are still up in arms about my comments. Stardock is a product, not a buddy who hangs out at your house or your family!

ioniangod21 .... Stardock is actually NOT a product, it's a company, and for many of us [if not all] that company is comprised of people we know and respect ['buddies', even] and we're currently here 'hanging out' with them...

Oh, and we do have freedom of speech here in Oz....for example, I could publicly say that lil Johnny (our Prime Minister) "is a low-life lying piece of pond scum who could lie under 40 foot of sewage with a mouth chocked full of parliamentary privileges, and wouldn't tell the truth if it were indelibly stamped to his tongue" and nobody would bat an eyelid.

Actually, Starkers....we [Australia] don't have 'freedom of speech' at all.  Generally people think we are like the US, but we ain't.

Instead, what you find there with your comment as quoted is a bloody long, hard search on yer hands if you want to find anyone who does NOT agree with it....

Wincustomize.com [and Stardock] are US-based so in that regard 'FOS' does apply.

However, being privately-owned entities they can addend to 'FOS' with.....'personal attack of your fellow site member is not acceptable', etc. ....

Reply #98 Top
How about you go back to school and read about freedom of speech because where you come from, there obviously is none.

Remember that thought when your Mommy is at the voting booth next time, Fidel Castro's unfortunately not on the ballet, sorry..............


I'll try, be hard though, difficult to remember the road there, it was 40 years ago.

I doubt mother will be too fussed, she's dead, anyway I dont think Castro will make it on the next ballot - he's at death's door.
Reply #99 Top
You know, I'm quite certain Mitsubishi could have thrown in a DVD/navigation system "and still made a profit" on the vehicle I bought last month. So what's your friggin' point? Does that mean they've "missed a golden marketing opportunity" & are therefore doomed? Make your own cost/value decision & be done with it.
Reply #100 Top
What the poster of this thread shows is an utter miss-understanding of why Stardock is here. Microsft over-sold with Ultimate and underdelivered, Stardock is doing what they were contracted to do and if they put out a premium dream they should be compensated for it.

I fail to see how a pretty interface can't be changed in other ways, I think Vista gives Stardock even more to work with, not less.

Just my 2 cents.