Island Dog Island Dog

Piracy and Political Affiliation

Piracy and Political Affiliation

Is one side more receptive than the other?

Piracy, whether it be of games, movies, software, or music is a pretty hot topic these days.  On one side you have people against piracy who usually claim copyright should be protected and what people are doing is just plain stealing.  On the other side there are people who think attempts to squash piracy are against someones "freedom" and argue that piracy doesn't affect the bottom line in business.

I have been looking through a bunch of websites that one could say the readers are more "supportive" of piracy and I noticed that what seems like a majority of these people seem to also be vocal in U.S. politics.  It also seems many of these people lean more to the left of the political spectrum, although I can't find any data to officially back that up with.  However, I think it's an interesting question to ask.  Does ones political affiliation and beliefs lessen or strengthen their stance on piracy?

Now before people get all bent out of shape, let me say I'm not accusing someone of advocating piracy because they are more liberal or conservative, but I do have my personal theory that one side is more receptive of the practice than another.  It's common to hear that people who are younger are typically more receptive to piracy than someone much older, but you never here much about their political, or even religious, preferences.

My belief is people who are more liberal, meaning fairly far left, will be more likely to accept the practice of piracy.  Why do I think that?  Well first of all, far left thinking is that capitalism is bad, and anyone who makes a profit is somehow "evil".  This also goes back to the reality that liberalism is more in favor of entitlement, and that someone who makes money somehow "owes" it back to society.  This creates an attitude of basically "I don't care" and that stealing someones copyrighted material doesn't mean anything because they are retaliating against the "greedy" industry.

What is your opinion?  Do you think an individuals political leaning affects their stance on piracy, or do you think it has no connection at all?

109,479 views 119 replies
Reply #101 Top
Taking without paying is theft plain and simple...ask any politician.
End of quote

They would know since most are thieves. Matter of fact, all of the politicians I've met are.
Reply #102 Top
Matter of fact, all of the politicians I've met are.
End of quote


Don't worry CarGuy...the politicians you haven't met are the same way....... ;p 
Reply #103 Top
Oh goodness....
End of quote


Whats the matter ID? You don't think Mr. I'mGonnaSaveTheWorld could be viewed as a terrorist just because he's an American president? You need to think outside of this country and really really look at what he's doing. As far as I'm concerned he's no better than the ones he's claiming to rid the world of...which in itself is just the most unobtainable and ridiculous idea ever. And I think its safe to say there are far more people that would agree with that than not.
Reply #104 Top

Whats the matter ID? You don't think Mr. I'mGonnaSaveTheWorld could be viewed as a terrorist just because he's an American president? You need to think outside of this country and really really look at what he's doing. As far as I'm concerned he's no better than the ones he's claiming to rid the world of...which in itself is just the most unobtainable and ridiculous idea ever. And I think its safe to say there are far more people that would agree with that than not.
End of quote

I think most people may think he's a bit of a putz....not the sharpest knife in the drawer...but calling him a 'terrorist' is about the greatest giggle since people called Frogboy a Nazi.

Well, 'giggle' is wrong....'sadly naive and ill-informed' is better.  I live 'outside this country' and see him quite clearly.

Either way, it's taking this thread well and truly off-topic.  The issue/question is can piracy be seen as more prevalent/accepted within one political stance than another?

What say we stay reasonably close to there, OK?....;)

Reply #105 Top
I find that the people I know who pirate software are Liberal rather than Conservative.

I, however, am Conservative, and though I do not pirate (except occasional abandonware, but I can justify that for greater justice, as opposed to stealing stuff that still sells), I cannot find any rationale to. If you can afford a computer, you can afford software. I don't care that Photoshop costs $100+. Use GIMP.
Reply #106 Top
I don't care that Photoshop costs $100+. Use GIMP.
End of quote


Thats a bit ignorant. Some people have a little thing called personal preference. In many cases GIMP doesn't quite cut it, and no i'm not saying that people should download/pirate photoshop because they prefer it.(which is a hell of a lot more than $100.) That wasn't exactly the best example to use...
Reply #107 Top

I think most people may think he's a bit of a putz....not the sharpest knife in the drawer...but calling him a 'terrorist' is about the greatest giggle since people called Frogboy a Nazi.
End of quote

I get called Nazi or Fascist so often it just has lost all meaning.  :)

Reply #108 Top
'sadly naive and ill-informed' is better.
End of quote


Guess that depends on your point of view and what you consider informed. Being "informed" only goes as far as the media or the government wishes to inform you....after that you have to inform yourself...or...think for yourself. I see things for what they are...not what I'm being told to think or believe. And I see Bush as a terrorists....and I'm not asking anyone to agree with that. I see no good coming from what he's doing in Iraq...none whatsoever. These are people that think killing themselves and going to where ever they are going to get a harem of virgins...yeah...they really care about democracy. They don't even care about here in the U.S.

He may have not started out as a terrorists....but he has become one.

the issue/question is can piracy be seen as more prevalent/accepted within one political stance than another?
End of quote


Simply stated...no.

People are to quick to change political stances to pin them down so that line of thinking is flawed. You might as well insert someones vegetable preference or anything else in there and the results would be the same.

I get called Nazi or Fascist so often it just has lost all meaning.
End of quote


Thats really sad that you get called those things. I for one have never seen or thought of you that way. I think its great that your achieving your goals and supporting your family doing something you enjoy. ;)

More power to you...but not to much power. :LOL:
Reply #109 Top
And I see Bush as a terrorists....and I'm not asking anyone to agree with that. I see no good coming from what he's doing in Iraq...none whatsoever.
End of quote


You are right, your views cannot be pigeon holed as liberal. Loony maybe, but then even most liberals are not so loony as to call Bush a Terrorist. Just remember, hate takes as much energy as love, and are not opposites, but instead 2 facets of the same side of the coin.
Reply #110 Top
You are right, your views cannot be pigeon holed as liberal. Loony maybe, but then even most liberals are not so loony as to call Bush a Terrorist.
End of quote


Like I said...I see him for what he is. The only difference between him and the ones blowing themselves up is he sends your kids to do it for him. I bet all those innocent Iraqi's who's children are being blown to bits so this idiot Bush can "liberate" them think he's a saint huh? I bet they feel real liberated!

Just remember, hate takes as much energy as love, and are not opposites, but instead 2 facets of the same side of the coin.
End of quote


And you think I'm loony? :LOL: Yeah...I bet the innocent Iraqi's are saying that right now. I can just hear them ..."Yes...flip that coin over...we must stop this hate...George loves us! He has liberated our whole family...all over what used to be the sidewalk albeit...but they are liberated! Thank you George!" ;p

Reply #111 Top
See reply 104 . . . .
You want to continue the "Bush is a terrorist" theme? Head over to JoeUser and a new thread.   :(
Reply #112 Top
You want to continue the "Bush is a terrorist" theme? Head over to JoeUser and a new thread.
End of quote


I'm a member here....not JoeUser. And as long as I'm being referred to as a loony I will reply. Otherwise I'm done here.

:(

Reply #113 Top
And I'm a member here....not JoeUser.
End of quote
If you are a member here . .you are a member there.  ;)
Glad your done though.
Reply #114 Top

You need to think outside of this country and really really look at what he's doing.
End of quote

I really don't care what people "outside" of this country think.  These are people who support people like Saddam, Osama, etc. so what the "world" thinks of Bush really means crap to be honest.  Just remember if people from "the world" had their way, real terrorists and dictators would be running the world.  ;)

 

You want to continue the "Bush is a terrorist" theme? Head over to JoeUser and a new thread
End of quote

Well to be fair, this thread was started on JoeUser.  :)

 

 

Reply #115 Top
Well to be fair, this thread was started on JoeUser.
End of quote
Doh!    ;p
Reply #116 Top
For my part...I apologize to ID for this getting somewhat off topic...but not for my views. And I still see no relation between piracy and politics.

And I would appreciate anyone having further thoughts about my views....please keep them to yourself since I will not revisit this thread since I've been asked to "take it elsewhere."

Thank you.
Reply #117 Top
And I would appreciate anyone having further thoughts about my views.
End of quote


I have several thought about your views...bweing they're very similar, p'raps we oughta start a "bash Bush" gripe thread t' air 'em without big brother Zubaz waving his big stick at us. :LOL:

Oh, and just wondering, if liberals have the greater propensity to pirate, would it stand to reason that under a liberal regime and court system, they'd get much lighter sentences than a conservative???? ;p
Reply #118 Top
without big brother Zubaz waving his big stick at us.
End of quote
Let's leave my big stick out of this. ;)
And while I disagree with some of the views here they are allowed (as always) as long as they are not personal attacks.  They just needed their own topic.
Oh, and just wondering, if liberals have the greater propensity to pirate, would it stand to reason that under a liberal regime and court system, they'd get much lighter sentences than a conservative????
End of quote
If the situation were as you stated . . I doubt there would be very much prosecution at all for anyone.  But there would be less risk to conservatives who pirated less.   :NOTSURE:
Reply #119 Top
Wow, lots or replies for what really was a simple question. I added my thoughts on the original question early on.  ;) 

I would like to add something that I feel very strong about. All the connecting the dots, as it were, to lead back to a political preference or slant as to why things happen is really funny for me and a total waste of time. Folks, who are much better able to explain why have tried to point it out.

I am also a believer in the "silent majority" in any society, culture or country, you know the ones that actually keep things going so you all have the time to be "politically correct". One of these days we are going to push back from the table, grab hold you and just slap the "silly" out of you.  :LOL: