Frogboy Frogboy

We need to give people more accolades

We need to give people more accolades

One of our top priorities when we created the site was to have a way of really giving users who are contributing to the site some accoldates.

That's why we track the top skin authors per category and top skins and such. But we shouldn't stop there I think.

One of the things we've been throwing around is the idea of having a points system for users. So that people who are contributing to the site in other ways can get more recognition.

Basically the idea works something like this:

When you make a post, you get 1 point for every 10 responses it gets.

When you submit news that gets accepted, you get a point.

For every 10 responses you make you get a point.

For every 5 responses on news items you get a point.

For every 100 downloads your skin gets you get a point.

For every article we publish of yours you get 1 point.

For every 100 people who view your article you get a point.

For every 5 comments you make on a skin you get a point.

Now, to keep people from writing "junk" responses, they would lose a point for every response/comment of theirs we had to delete (so if the person responded "Yea!" as their post, we could delete it and the user would lose 1 point -- we would just discretion, only if it was apparent the person was making the weak response for points would we do that).

This sort of point system would then let us have a hall of fame for top contributors to the site.

32,070 views 88 replies
Reply #76 Top
I'd say the difference here vs. the Stardock NGs is that on the Stardock NGs Brad or someone will post an idea and people will say "Hmm that is interesting, what if you did this or that and that might make it better." And then someone else will add there 2-cents. But here, Brad or someone will post an idea and you get a bunch of people just saying why it's a bad idea without saying what they think might be a better idea.
Reply #77 Top
NG ppl and msg board posters are two diff breeds
hehe

Brad should know that he's been around the boards long enough

A post about trying to give kudos to people who help the site turns into yet another evil conspiracy. Yet if Lotsofskins does it, it's okay.
by Mr Frank Leon - 7/16/2001 12:27:53 PM

not the same Frank...
points over at LOS give you a cool icon period.

Reply #78 Top
My only fear is that what would happen is that more skin sites will arrive and people will go there to chat and hang out in discussions and then just use this site for their downloading.
by Admin Frogboy - 7/16/2001 8:04:51 PM

Hopefully that will not happen Brad but if it did just close shop for a while until the issues are resolved with the cost better =/

Anyway, this is my last response on this topic. I think I'm going to take a break from WinCustomize for awhile.
by Admin Frogboy - 7/16/2001 11:20:43 PM

Brad relax and have some fun everybody loves the Frog! hehe
(it will all work itself out at the right time)
Reply #79 Top
Geez... this thread is getting too damn long to keep up with. I could read a Stephen King novel in less time.

Reply #80 Top
looks like i missed out on a good topic. i think it would be fun for some of us to get an idea how we contribute to the community of users of the site.

tandis and doreen, well each website has its own feel. there are tons of delphi message boards and each group has its own character. the skins websites kind of make me envision a scene in which a couple of people are doing a bunch of hard work and they are surrounded by a bunch of people lounging in laz-e-boy chairs bitching about what they're doing while not lifting a finger themselves to help. i don't see that in this topic but i really remember seeing it in other topics in the past. every skin site from skinz.org on has that. people used to just sit around nitpicking shoggot and mian and toasty while not offering any help themselves. that's what i miss about skinz.org, toasty wasn't afraid to tell whiners to go f themselves sometimes.
Reply #81 Top
having been away for a while, i am coming to this late

on this points idea, there is concern that "3 or 4" people will abuse it with lots of posts designed just to get points. surely this would be obvious to all concerned? in that case, if the people wont see reason, then just stop giving them points for posts?

my other concern is, what about posters who are more "reality challanged" than others? i just hope that they wont be discriminated against for making less directly relivent posts
/me is feeling paranoid, they may have found where i berried those stealth helicopters
Reply #82 Top
Points? Best skin authors?
I think the best rating is the utility and the pleasant use of a skin.
Is right to award the participation in forums, notices, comments, etc. Yes, but for the users like me (that my thoughts are in catalan - a non english langage) that they do not know to write in English, cannot put in the Web many comments. I am learning English too much quickly
But a good idea would be to award the skins by a system in which the users said as they are his prettier skins, and most useful.
this forum is a site where people can express themselves freely, and where to put ideas, not a site in order to accumulate points.
I prefer that a user says to me that skins is contented with my, and that has found them useful, not to accumulate points or to be number one. When I paid the Object Desktop, my intentions were to have one better interface; luck that I was decided to do skins, more is amused than to use them!
Reply #84 Top
craeonics the bitch - now there is an interesting thought. wrong species, but canine is definetly getting closer to feline.
soon we will be there [mannic laughter]
Reply #85 Top
'manic', feline.....Spell checker
Reply #86 Top
what, me manic?
what a suggestion
Reply #87 Top
i say just keep it the way it is if it's not briken don't fix it i'm new to things i'v started with skinning when i find out what program i can use to realy change the look of winamp i'd want to be posting it here i like the way this site is now don't change it.
Reply #88 Top
i think the 100 downloads thing is a bad idea, people will just download skins just because they will get points, this can be misleading to the author, i get a buzz when i see people have downloaded my wallpapers, but, i would be unsure if people are downloading them because they like them, or if they just want points