Is Free Trade Agreement broken?

I established a Free Trade Agreement with the Thalans playing the Contingency part of the base game campaign. If I hover over the FTA help text it states "Give a 25% bonus to the wealth of both civilizations through the sharing of Markets". I have observed a zero increase in income. Is this a known bug with 1.9?

Regards,

Nethog

19,206 views 6 replies
Reply #1 Top

Its a bug since beta(?),

it actually only gives a wealth-bonus to the recieving faction,

the same is true for the other treatys as well.

Reply #2 Top

Thanks. Is it possible to trade FTA for FTA from the other party to make FTA work as it should?

Regards

Nethog

Reply #3 Top

It is utterly broken, like most of the diplomatic contracts. Treaties are doing something different than described, non-agression can be broken any time, when your allies are attacked you don“t even get a dialogue prompting you to join them or break the alliance. Even Total War games have this and in Stardock games diplomacy is broken in this regard since FE ;P

Hopefully it gets fixed some day...

Reply #4 Top

Agreed, the treaty aspect to diplomacy need a complete overhaul. Alliances appear to be only pre-requisites to a victory condition, rather than a strategic arrangement that could help weaker powers fend of attacks. 

Reply #5 Top

Ok thanks. I am a little disappointed that a game that has been out for quite a while now still has broken gameplay, especially from a company like Stardock.

Reply #6 Top

Quoting Nethog61, reply 5

Ok thanks. I am a little disappointed that a game that has been out for quite a while now still has broken gameplay, especially from a company like Stardock.
End of Nethog61's quote

Yeah. Surprisingly, Stardock would be precisely the kind of company I would expect to strongly focus on Diplomacy aspect of the game. Yet believe me, some of the issues (useless alliances) are being discussed since Fallen Enchantress, which is maybe like 5 years ago.