uDigItTheMost uDigItTheMost

Who's Your Favorite Guitarist

Who's Your Favorite Guitarist

of All-Time

I'm asking who's your favorite. Your favorites who are still living, and your favorites who are no longer living. They don't have to be who you think is the greatest, just ones you like for whatever reason. The only thing I ask is to keep each question to 3 answers or less. I know that's asking alot considering how many fantastic players there really are all there. I had trouble sticking with my own request but I narrowed it down.

My 3 favorite guitarists that are no longer with us is:

STEVIE RAY VAUGHAN - His first album is still my favorite from him. I absolutely love the song "Texas Flood" from it. I was very fortunate to see him in concert 7 times.

JIMI HENDRIX - When I was young my father bought me a stereo from a garage sale. It had an 8-track player, my uncle gave me my first 8-track, "Smash Hits" from Jimi. I been a fan ever since.

KURT COBAIN - Singer, songwriter and guitarist from Nirvana. As great as "Nevermind" was, I was blown away by "Unplugged in New York". From beginning to end it's perfection.

My 3 favorite living guitarists are:

BUDDY GUY - I'm embarrassed to say I used to think he didn't match up with Robert Johnson, B.B. King or Muddy Waters. One day on the way to a blues festival, I heard "A Man and the Blues", then I seen him performed, made me realize how dumb I been. Possibly the greatest living guitarist.

TOM MORELLO - The guitarist for one of my favorite bands of all-time, Rage Against the Machine. Unfortunately the group broke up. If you never heard them, get their self-titled debut album or "The Battle of Los Angeles". Very good live. He nows plays in the group Audioslave.

JACK WHITE - Guitarist, singer and songwriter from the group The White Stripes. A friend of mine gave me a bootleg tape of him doing a Son House song, which made me buy their album "White Blood Cells". I rank it every good as Nirvana's Unplugged in New York. Another one who's great live, if you have the chance to see him perform, go. Very underrated guitarist.

Okay that just made me think of another question - Who's the most overrated guitarist?

My choice ( and I might get some flack for this) is:

TED NUGENT - Some friends I grew up with think he's in the top ten. I never been a fan of his. He doesn't suck. I always like his song "Strangehold", and if I heard it just one time a year "Cat Scratch Fever" wouldn't be bad either. Tell me your choices.
37,923 views 68 replies
Reply #26 Top
--Most people do not even know stevie vai I am suprised you do.--

Is he still around? Is he playing with anyone? Touring solo or with a group? He's too talented to have stopped.

--If you liked the mothers, you may want to check these guys out.--

Thanks for the link, Mod. Deep Purple's Smoke on the Water just popped in my head.

Frank Zappa and the Mothers
Were at the best place around
But some stupid with a flare gun
Burned the place to the ground
Smoke on the water, fire in the sky
Reply #27 Top
--Paco DeLuca. If you ever get the chance to listen to Dimeola, DeLuca and Laughlin live at the Fillmore you will not be disappointed. Possibly some of the BEST flamenco-style guitar I have ever heard.--

Great choice. I forgot all about them. "Friday Night in San Francisco"

---Charlie Hunter. Link My friend introduced me to him years ago, and...absolutely amazing. His album 'Duo' is fairly simple, but you have to admire a person who can fill the lead guitar and bass parts plaing the same guitar. Which brings me to...

Michael Manring. Link When the same friend played the song 'Monkey Businessman' off the linked album, I was at a loss for words. This guy made a bass guitar sound like a full-fledged band. I wish I had 1/100th the talent that this guy has. And speaking of bass players...

Jaco Pastorius. Long since passed away, I'd have to say that he's probably influenced more guitarists and bassists than you would guess.---

I'm sad to say I only heard of Michael Manring, and even sadder to say I haven't heard music from either three. Thanks so much for the links.

--Les Claypool. I just gotta love this guy because he came from the same town I grew up in.--

He puts on a such a good show visually you forget how good of a bassist he is. Did you know he tried out for Metallica?
Reply #28 Top
--Given an instrumental by him, or a collaboration(I bought all the early Santana Albums!  My Ex stole them from me), I would go with his instrumental.  I like many of the other guitarist, but he just gets to me like no others can.--

What's with the ex stealing your collection? I know how you feel though I had 2 German bootleg albums of Hendrix that an ex stole. One of the albums had a 26 minute version of Red House, too. I want that album back so much.

Carlos was in town last night. Tickets sold out too fast for me to go see him. Robert Randolph opened up for him, too. I wanted to go I seen Santana in concert a few times but not Robert Randolph.

--He Plays Bass.  I bought him a new base a couple of years ago.  And as repayment, he learned the rif from Dazed and Confused!  It was awesome!  Almost like seeing Zeplin in concert!  He may not be the best, but he is one of my favorites!--

Nothing wrong with being a bass player. Them and the drummers are a big part of the band. And definitely nothing wrong in his taste in music, either. I bet you were a proud papa listening.
Reply #29 Top
I like Phil Keaggy.

And my Uncle Chris Jammin' with him is so fun, because no matter what *I* play on keyboards, he makes it all sound good.
Reply #30 Top
--Jimi Hendrix, Ted Nugent, Stevie Ray Vaughn, Billy Gibbons... Gee- there's really no place to stop!--

ZZ Top kicks ass in concert. I have never been disappointed at one of their shows.
Reply #31 Top
--I like Phil Keaggy.--

The first I heard of Phil Keaggy was in a urban legend. According to legend, during a Tonight Show appearance, when asked who was the greatest guitarist ever Jimi Hendrix responded it was Phil Keaggy. It trurns out the rumor was false.

Though during The Dick Cavett Show, Jimi did praise a pre-ZZ Top Billy Gibbons, then an unknown guitarist with a group named Moving Sidewalks.

--And my Uncle Chris Jammin' with him is so fun, because no matter what *I* play on keyboards, he makes it all sound good--

But could he make my singing sound good?
btw .. I think he's good because of his name and I won't tell you my name.
Reply #32 Top
Favorite?

Me, and I'm not even that good. But I sure do like me. In fact, I'm so not good at guitar that I switched to bass. I can play anything else, but I can't bar chord for crap either. B.B. King rocks. (although I do agree, I like John Lee Hooker better.) Screw you, Iconoclast.

Real guitarists? A guy you've never heard of by the name of Jim Simmons. He never made it big, but he was one of the most amazing players I ever heard. I also like a guy named Jody Evans who used to be a friend of mine. Nothing fancy, but I like his sound.
Reply #33 Top
dead:

robert johnson
'magic' sam maghett
roy buchannan
reverend gary davis
mississipi john hurt
wes montgomery
les paul
george harrison
guitar slim
sam 'lightnin' hopkins
pete glover's friend

living:

buddy
bb king (who doesn't need to bar chords)
taj mahal
steve cropper
mick taylor
richards
larry carsman
stuart smith

other guitars:

david lindley
ry cooder

maybe dead or not...i'm unsure:

jeremy spenser

clapton coulda never recorded anything but the first bluesbreakers' album and it woulda been enuff to establish his greatness. everything else is a bonus.
Reply #34 Top
dammit it's too damn difficult to do this. even trying to limit myself to blues artists (too difficult as well), i have too many favorites.

add jimmy vaughn to my list.
Reply #35 Top
People forget that Blues and Rock N Roll were basically invented for those who aren't "great" at an instrument. As with everything else, Rock N Roll has progressed in many different directions with musicians taking it in as many directions as they feel the urge.

Metal, Punk and Grunge each served the purpose of bringing Rock & Roll back to that concept for the generations in which they were "invented".

Metal was the late 60's answer to "glam" rock; Punk was the 70s answer to Progressive Rock, and Grunge reminded us that guitars were not just for "hair bands".

It's interesting to me that the "hair bands" took the glam of "glam rock" and made it their own... "New Wave" introduced "progress" to the punk scene and what we call "alternative" today is a progressive twist to grunge.

So, not that I don't have a soft spot in my musical heart for Prog Rock, and I still listen to The Ramones, and really liked Nirvana... I wonder what will happen next to remind us that Rock N Roll isn't highly technical notes, scales and chords in a melodic manipulation of sound and silence... it's merely fun music that anyone can play. ;~D
Reply #36 Top
Steve Vai was with Frank Zappa for awhile.

Damn. I don't know how I could have forgotten Ritchie Blackmore. Deep Purple was my favorite band for about 30 years.
Reply #37 Top

Nothing wrong with being a bass player. Them and the drummers are a big part of the band. And definitely nothing wrong in his taste in music, either. I bet you were a proud papa listening.

Does it show?

Reply #38 Top
I agree, Ted's the most overrated. But he's only overrated because he's louder'n everyone else....lol
Reply #39 Top

--Most people do not even know stevie vai I am suprised you do.--

Is he still around? Is he playing with anyone? Touring solo or with a group? He's too talented to have stopped.


do not know where he is last time I saw him anywhere he was the devils Haircutter in "CROSSROADS" the movie with ralph Macchio. {sp?}
Reply #40 Top
he is on tour right now with a band called the breed. but the fucker is only doing europe. waaaaaaaaa!!!!!
Reply #41 Top
SeƱor Jorge Orozco

and some others...classical or Spanish guitarists, I've felt have always been cut differently from blues guitarists.
Reply #42 Top
--Me, and I'm not even that good. But I sure do like me. In fact, I'm so not good at guitar that I switched to bass. I can play anything else, but I can't bar chord for crap either. B.B. King rocks. (although I do agree, I like John Lee Hooker better.--

At the bar, where I play poker tournaments at, has one of those internet jukeboxes and every week I play a lot of blues. I heard one guy say to another guy,"Who is this?" when John Lee Hooker's Boom Boom was on. Last week when I was there again the same guy who asked the question played it.

--Real guitarists? A guy you've never heard of by the name of Jim Simmons. He never made it big, but he was one of the most amazing players I ever heard. I also like a guy named Jody Evans who used to be a friend of mine. Nothing fancy, but I like his sound.--

I wonder how many "Jim Simmons" are out there. A older brother of a friend used to tell us about some incredible player who according to him "would blow away Eddie Van Halen".
Reply #43 Top
---robert johnson
'magic' sam maghett
roy buchannan
reverend gary davis
mississipi john hurt
wes montgomery
les paul
george harrison
guitar slim
sam 'lightnin' hopkins
pete glover's friend---

I see you DO like blues guitarist. Roy Buchannan is another underrated guitarists. I only have one from Wes Montgomery,"The Incredible Jazz Guitar" one. Who's Pete Glover's friend?

--buddy
bb king (who doesn't need to bar chords)
taj mahal
steve cropper
mick taylor
richards
larry carsman
stuart smith--

Reminds me of how two of my friends used to argue constantly over which player was better. And one of their fights was over who was a better rhythm guitarists - Steve Cropper or Keith Richards.

--other guitars:

david lindley
ry cooder--

Even Ry Cooder's soundtrack work is good.

--clapton coulda never recorded anything but the first bluesbreakers' album and it woulda been enuff to establish his greatness. everything else is a bonus.--

It's how I feel about Stevie's first one.

--add jimmy vaughn to my list.--

Is he playing with Double Trouble?
Reply #44 Top
--#35 by ParaTed2k
Sunday, October 09, 2005 --

Your whole post deserves an insightful, Ted.

--People forget that Blues and Rock N Roll were basically invented for those who aren't "great" at an instrument.--

It's the same reason I sing rock and roll.
Reply #45 Top
--Damn. I don't know how I could have forgotten Ritchie Blackmore. Deep Purple was my favorite band for about 30 years.--

Every time I hear about Ritchie Blackmore, the first thing that pops in my head is how much Eddie Van Halen would bad mouth him. Anybody out there know why?
Reply #46 Top
--Does it show?--

Just a tad.
Reply #47 Top
--I agree, Ted's the most overrated. But he's only overrated because he's louder'n everyone else--

And his guitar playing is loud, too.
Reply #48 Top
----do not know where he is last time I saw him anywhere he was the devils Haircutter in "CROSSROADS" the movie with ralph Macchio.--

Crossroads wasn't a bad movie. Ry Cooder did the music score for the movie.

--he is on tour right now with a band called the breed. but the fucker is only doing europe. waaaaaaaaa!!!!--

Reply #49 Top
--SeƱor Jorge Orozco

and some others...classical or Spanish guitarists, I've felt have always been cut differently from blues guitarists.--

I've heard some spanish guitarists but I never heard of him. Will have to check him out.

Believe it or not, the reason I got into spanish guitar was from listening to Tesla. A girl I knew said the beginning of one of their songs sounded like a spanish guitar. So I bought some tapes cause of Tesla. Yeah right, who am I kidding? I bought them cause of the girl.
Reply #50 Top
I agree, Ted's the most overrated. But he's only overrated because he's louder'n everyone else....lol


Ok, I know I'm loud, but "Overrated"? I didn't even know I was "rated". ;~D