I'm in the same boat here. I had favor points earned in single player. The first time I tried multiplayer, when I stepped out, my favor points were gone, and I was a sad panda. I'm curious if the transition from single player to learn the ropes, to multiplayer to get my butt kicked, is what nuked my favor.
I hate that more and more games ship without a campaign. Hate it. With all the demigods' backstories in this game, there could've been some really fun campaign play, and even a meh story can hold my attention through some really annoying gameplay. BUT--no campaign was advertised, and I'm having a fantastic time in Pantheon right now, despite being one of the unlucky sods with negative favor points (even though I typically finish first on my side, if not the whole match, on
Demigod Forums