GM-McShane87

Reply to The 2nd Demigod Community Tournament - Decision Making Panel Discussions in Demigod Demigod Forums

[quote who="Zen_God" reply="242" id="2844003"] Quoting GM-McShane87, reply 240 Quoting Zen_God, reply 238I have my finals this week. can we set the due dates after this week? omg there is a newer version of ueberfix now, you guys are making this complicated. Lol no. What did you have for the last month that you couldn't play or find an alternate for mith. Orcun's gone for a month and a half after the 18th, you're disqualified if you don't play on or before Tue

Reply to The 2nd Demigod Community Tournament - Scheduling in Demigod Demigod Forums

[quote who="Zen_God" reply="217" id="2843918"]I hope mith popps up or i have to find and alternate:([/quote] nnills is back after a month long break.

Reply to The 2nd Demigod Community Tournament - Decision Making Panel Discussions in Demigod Demigod Forums

[quote who="Zen_God" reply="238" id="2843906"]I have my finals this week. can we set the due dates after this week? omg there is a newer version of ueberfix now, you guys are making this complicated.[/quote] Lol no. What did you have for the last month that you couldn't play or find an alternate for mith. Orcun's gone for a month and a half after the 18th, you're disqualified if you don't play on or before Tuesday. I have finals this week also, but 3 or 4 hours

Reply to The 2nd Demigod Community Tournament - Scheduling in Demigod Demigod Forums

I'm guessing Orcun and Renz will come on within the next few hours and then we should be available for the rest of the day. I'm available tomorrow and Tuesday as well from 4 PM until 1 AM.

Reply to The 2nd Demigod Community Tournament - Decision Making Panel Discussions in Demigod Demigod Forums

Perfect

Reply to The 2nd Demigod Community Tournament - Decision Making Panel Discussions in Demigod Demigod Forums

[quote who="OMG_ZEX" reply="233" id="2843262"]I don't see what is wrong with adding whatever jona's team wants as a DG team to the selections. There will just be four selections vs three.[/quote] We did that, it's also perfectly fine but he's still unhappy because we're doing mirror matches. So sticking with the original rules for the first round is the other option.

Reply to The 2nd Demigod Community Tournament - Decision Making Panel Discussions in Demigod Demigod Forums

Alright so finals use the new character selections for sure. We'll let Jona decide if he wants to stick with the original tourney rules whenever they get on to play against us. We're available all day tomorrow Jona.

Reply to The 2nd Demigod Community Tournament - Decision Making Panel Discussions in Demigod Demigod Forums

[quote]But yeah i agree the change of rules looks a bit one-sided and there's an over-abundance of Erebus (3 times) and UB (2) in contrast with the lack of Oak/Sedna/Oculus. I've honestly had enough of Sedna and Oculus (as well as UB...) in the current tournament but Oak could easily replace Erebus in at least one of the proposed combos. My vote would have gone for free-for-all, one-by-one DG picking with no DG repetition per team (9 different demigods in each team through the 3 ga

Reply to The 2nd Demigod Community Tournament - Decision Making Panel Discussions in Demigod Demigod Forums

[quote]We want Occ TB Rook added to the combos.[/quote] Sure we'll do Occ-TB-Rook with you. If we don't agree to mirror match beforehand it just means we have to go through some more points shit all over again, that's already been decided. I thought it was just going to be different character selection rules for the championship game, but didn't work out that way. Maybe we stick with the original rules for the first round if Zen wants to and since Jona clear

Reply to The 2nd Demigod Community Tournament - Decision Making Panel Discussions in Demigod Demigod Forums

Nom's always here he could have posted. No other way to do it with 4 teams, and tbh if we stick with the original rules that's more favored to Renz than this is. We were originally going to pick them without Zen's team having any say, not our fault he showed up out of nowhere.

Reply to The 2nd Demigod Community Tournament - Decision Making Panel Discussions in Demigod Demigod Forums

[quote]Here are the combos: * QoT, erebus, UB * Rook-TB-Oak * ub tb erebus[/quote] Change ours to Rook-Reg-Erebus please, still beat Jona so we're good and we need a Reg in there somewhere.

Reply to The 2nd Demigod Community Tournament - Decision Making Panel Discussions in Demigod Demigod Forums

[quote]Quoting OMG_pacov, reply 181 I really don't think my team and mcshane's will have any problem getting our games in... even if we waited until thursday, though. But whatever gets us moving is cool with me. So, we agree that we drop zen_god's team if they have not played by tuesday night? Correct? Correct[/quote] It's Tuesday night, not Wednesday.

Reply to The 2nd Demigod Community Tournament - Decision Making Panel Discussions in Demigod Demigod Forums

We'll take Rook-TB-Oak

Reply to The 2nd Demigod Community Tournament - Decision Making Panel Discussions in Demigod Demigod Forums

So then we should have had a vote. There's no reasonable way for you and I to pick 3 that will make everyone happy, unless we just go with one from each team. If there's a third game in any of the series it will just be decided by a different teams preferred combo since the teams will take turns picking the one they nominated.

Reply to The 2nd Demigod Community Tournament - Decision Making Panel Discussions in Demigod Demigod Forums

[quote]So, here's what I'll do to clarify (HOPEFULLY) - mcshane - you are on the decision making panel. Do you second my vote for us doing mirror matches for the final 4 part of our tournament? If so, then THAT is set in stone.[/quote] Yes I like mirror matches. [quote]And your idea, mcshane, about using 1 combo from each team doesn't necessarily work - remember, this part of the tournament is elimination after the best 2 out of 3 games. Whatever the 3rd combo is might not

Reply to The 2nd Demigod Community Tournament - Decision Making Panel Discussions in Demigod Demigod Forums

I don't think Pacov read reply 176 from cow, or he doesn't agree to it whatever. Looks like Zen's not going to show up today with picks, so maybe we just use one from each team.

Reply to The 2nd Demigod Community Tournament - Decision Making Panel Discussions in Demigod Demigod Forums

[quote who="OMG_pacov" reply="203" id="2842601"]The final decision is up to the panel, but I want to hear feedback from ANYONE involved (as again frankly, I'm likely up for however we'll switch things up). [/quote] How can it be up to the panel? You're just going to say you want your teams picks and I'll want my teams picks. That was the point of the nominations, so it could be voted on. Anyone votes and the top 3 character selections are what we play.

Reply to The 2nd Demigod Community Tournament - Decision Making Panel Discussions in Demigod Demigod Forums

Pacov I don't think it's clear that people not involved in the tournament can vote on this. Even Orcun thought it was up to the decision making panel. Each team says who they would like to use and then we're taking the top 3 picks from community votes, might need a whole new post. If no one votes then maybe we need to take turns picking the matchup and then a free for all.

Reply to The 2nd Demigod Community Tournament - Decision Making Panel Discussions in Demigod Demigod Forums

Each game will be a different mirror match, people got tired of seeing the same one every game. The other option could have just been to say no Occ-Sed-UB but a different mirror match each game should be fun.

Reply to The 2nd Demigod Community Tournament - Decision Making Panel Discussions in Demigod Demigod Forums

[quote who="OMG_Jona" reply="188" id="2842062"]Ok games are over won both games[/quote] Make sure to talk to your team about what characters you guys want to use Jona before they leave. Submit 3 different selections to be voted on.

Reply to The 2nd Demigod Community Tournament - Decision Making Panel Discussions in Demigod Demigod Forums

....

Reply to The 2nd Demigod Community Tournament - Decision Making Panel Discussions in Demigod Demigod Forums

[quote who="OMG_Jona" reply="188" id="2842062"]Ok games are over won both games[/quote] Sweet. When can you play us? I wanted to try to sneak in as soon as you guys played your second game, but now we have to pick characters I guess.

Reply to The 2nd Demigod Community Tournament - Decision Making Panel Discussions in Demigod Demigod Forums

Looks like there's going to be a 4th team so we gotta start this vote tonight. The official nominations for my team are: 1. Rook-UB-Reg 2. Rook-TB-Oak 3. Erebus-DA-Sedna Cow's team: 4. Sed, UB, Reg 5. Rook, QoT, Oak 6. QoT, Erebus, UB You should throw that into the original post Pacov, or make a new one so people can start voting.

Reply to The 2nd Demigod Community Tournament - Decision Making Panel Discussions in Demigod Demigod Forums

[quote who="OMG_pacov" reply="181" id="2841781"]I really don't think my team and mcshane's will have any problem getting our games in... even if we waited until thursday, though. But whatever gets us moving is cool with me. So, we agree that we drop zen_god's team if they have not played by tuesday night? Correct?[/quote] Correct

Reply to The 2nd Demigod Community Tournament - Decision Making Panel Discussions in Demigod Demigod Forums

Also I forgot with the character selections, Zen's team is probably going to just forfeit if there is not a TB or UB in every combo for Kira to play. I'm sure it's possible for him to play others, but he has like 10 total games with them combined.