greywar

greywar

Joined Member # 657217
17 Posts 146 Replies 29,532 Reputation

Brad - I don't have much to say about your article except to express my complete agreement with it's assessment. The "moral equivalency" argument is one of the most intellectually bereft memes I have ever had the misfortune of being exposed to.

46 Replies 9,509 Views

Jamaah Islamiyah is a benign Islamic organization? Gerry I think that this is very far from the case here. Abu Bakar Ba'ashir a member of this organization was responsible for the Bali bomings just to name one at random. Indonesia seems to yet *another* case where the majority *claim* to be moderates whiel doing nothing to stop or even mildy discourage the extremists in their midst .

37 Replies 5,527 Views

What are the causes for such terrorism in the first place? Is the *anything* that would ever justify this act Solitair? US Policy decisions or something? I am dying to know what cause could *possibly* matter. At all. You are seriously trying Moral equivalency here? That is not a defensible position. Attacks against civilian targets with no military units

76 Replies 26,988 Views

Second paragraph of the article you linked to: "The vote is seen as a bid to repair relations with the US and to play a role in the shaping of a future Iraq. It cheers the US, which is keen to bring in large numbers of Muslim troops to join coalition forces." As for the explanation of the differences I just finished outlining the major difference two comments ago. Additionally your article lacks a Bush or Rice quote and only has someone elses opinion of what

37 Replies 5,527 Views

OG - Actually there was a very small minority of the administration in favor of allowing Turkish troops into northern Iraq. If you will recall it was Turkey's insistance on being allowed to do so in exchange for basing rights that led the the war from the south. Bush did *not* want Turkey in Iraq at all at the beginning of the war. Find me a *single* quote from GWB stating that he did and I will retract the full article and issue and apology as long as the quote only attribution is not

37 Replies 5,527 Views

There are significant hurdles to the economic approach with Muslim nations though. It is difficult to sell the women clothes when wearing them is a stonable offense but I think the idea has tremendous merit.

12 Replies 1,424 Views

JakeD - lol, if they wanted to plant evidence they could do so easily and by the bushel. They would have *buried* Kerry with it already. Next tell me about how they are holding Bin Laden in a secret safehouse until October! You guys crack me up:)

30 Replies 14,052 Views

Again what sports? Outback extreme golf? Billabong rock-skipping? The hundred meter descended from prisoners-escapee dash? I kid Muggaz.... While in Korea the Star sports channel brought me Austrailian League Football, World Cup Rugby, and even cricket. They were the only things that kept me sane. Even if I did have to go online to even grasp the bare rudiments of cricket.

31 Replies 5,007 Views

"as close as we may seem upon inspection" Dharma - I don't think we seem to be very close to Iraq on many levels except the biological. Where as some of the more *extreme* Christian sects beleive in "an eye for an eye" and all that. Vocal Muslims seem to beleive in "a head for a fingernail". I find the behaviour of the soldiers in Abu Ghraib abhorrent and I don't think a 20-50 year prison sentence to be unreasonable for them but not execution.

12 Replies 1,424 Views

Gerry - Actually the title was meant as sarcasm intended to heap scorn on the content of the rest of the article which was just as ridiculous. Gerhardt went on to say that he wanted *local* Arab nations to be the peacekeepers. nation like say Jordan, Syria, Saudi and so on... The Arab league itself immediately denounced the plan as "stupid". All those nations surrounding would have a vested interest in simply taking over while they were there. This would of course necessitate *another* invasion

37 Replies 5,527 Views

I am sure Iran would be only to happy to cooperate in this little gem of a plan : (edit - Shroeder didn't mention Iran this is sarcasm on my part. Hat tip to Gerry Atrick for the heads up on vagueness) "I have doubts whether NATO is the best instrument available to bring stability there," Schroeder told reporters after meeting with Belgian Prime Minister Guy Verhofstadt. Schroeder, who ruled out

37 Replies 5,527 Views

I have made the same sort of slip fairly often. I am so used to saying "yeah like i said to my wife" that I will say it even when I mean someone else. This is a basis for criticism? Very thin folks, very thin.

5 Replies 6,055 Views